What’s my cyber risk?
Small and middle market businesses (SMB) tend to be less concerned about their technology/cyber risks than their publicly traded counterparts. How is this possible? It may be due primarily to a limited understanding of the scope of risks these organizations face.
According to the Verizon Data Breach Report, approximately 61% of data breach victims are businesses with less than 1,000 employees. With this in mind, let’s address some of the common misconceptions among SMBs:
- We’re not a target for attackers because we don’t have valuable data: Any business that processes data and is connected to the internet has cyber risk. It’s that simple. While SMBs often don’t have large ‘troves’ of data, they still have data. Attackers view access to SMB networks as a ‘path of least resistance.’ Compared to large publicly traded companies, SMBs may not have significant resources invested and dedicated to protecting their critical assets. As such, it is easier for a hacker to infiltrate a high volume of SMBs than one large organization with stronger controls.
- We outsource the storage/processing of data: Most SMBs think outsourcing data storage and processing will completely transfer their risk and potential liability to the outsource provider. This is NOT true. The organization that owns the data ultimately has responsibility for it. While there may be some shared liability with outsource providers, most have limit of liability provisions in their contracts. Further, determining liability is a lengthy process and something an organization will be challenged to devote time to while responding to a breach.
- We have adequate technology security controls: While technology controls are important and part of the solution, cyber risk at its core is a people risk. According to our research, 69% of cyber breaches are due to an organization’s employees and can stem from a lost laptop, a disgruntled employee, inadequate cyber awareness training or hiring non-qualified employees. Therefore, it is important to also devote attention and resources to people solutions, such as employee engagement, awareness and hiring the appropriate IT talent.
Which businesses should buy cyber risk insurance?
Both Business to Business (B2B) and Business to Consumer (B2C) organizations should understand their cyber risk and consider cyber insurance as a method of risk transfer.
For B2B organizations, it’s easier to understand why cyber insurance is important. When dealing with other businesses, there may be contractual requirements that require organizations to carry cyber insurance or technology professional services coverage.
If an organization is providing technology professional services, it’s important for them to put together technology professional services coverage with cyber liability insurance, as there’s an overlap in coverage. If an organization isn’t providing a technology professional service, it’s still important for them to consider cyber insurance, which can provide balance sheet protection for both first-party coverage (out of pocket expenses – i.e., business interruption, data restoration, and cyber extortion) and third-party liabilities (lawsuits alleging financial harm as a result of an organization’s errors or omissions).
For B2C organizations, historical buyers of cyber insurance were industries that held a lot of records (i.e., retail, healthcare and education); however, the more recent cyber claims have affected other industries such as manufacturing, nonprofits and critical infrastructure.
What are some possible cyber claims that could impact SMBs?
Here are a few examples from our Claims database, along with the outcomes:
An online retailer had noticed unusual activity on its server, which prompted an investigation. They discovered that hackers had stolen an employee’s credentials and used them to access the names, billing addresses and credit card numbers of approximately 50,000 customers during checkout.
Outcome: The insurer retained the appropriate vendors and notified the necessary individuals and agencies. The retailer incurred approximately $1M in first-party costs.
A hospital office employee had stolen medical profiles, histories and detailed personal information on approximately 125,000 patients.
Outcome: The insurer provided the client hospital with crisis support team, made up of outside vendors, to help resolve the breach and reimbursed the hospital approximately $800,000 for the crisis team’s expenses.
A consumer products company had undergone a software system upgrade performed by a vendor. The system upgrade failed, which caused all of the manufacturer’s systems to malfunction on the same day. This caused an unintentional and unplanned outage, which resulted in the suspension of the manufacturer’s operations.
Outcome: $2M was paid out for extra expenses associated with the business interruption, including expenses to continue normal business operations
Technology Professional Services
A technology services provider of software applications, implementation services and support contracted with a social welfare organization to consolidate and update its legacy IT systems. The social welfare organization filed suit against insured, claiming it failed to meet contractual deadlines, delivered a poorly performing system and failed to properly staff the project.
Outcome: The social welfare organization sought damages in excess of $15M.
A client’s computer server was maliciously attacked by a virus that encrypted their data and demanded a $5,000 ransom to unencrypt. The insured reported the matter to the FBI and local authorities, and refused to pay the ransom.
Outcome: The insurer engaged an expert to perform a forensic analysis of the client’s system. The expert found the impacted server didn’t contain any confidential information. They removed the virus and strengthened the client’s data security protections. The insurer reimbursed the insured $45,000 for forensic costs incurred.
Handling cyber breaches can be complex and expensive, and costs can easily amount to thousands of dollars or millions if an organization isn’t proactive. SMBs need to take advantage of cyber insurance, as it provides more than just a risk transfer. Think of it as a cyber hygiene assessment and partnership with the various parties that need to be involved in the event of a breach.
Most cyber insurers offer their policyholders a choice of breach response services, typically from a list of pre-approved vendors. Many allow the policyholders’ own choice of vendor. Most insurers also grant policyholders access to a complimentary cyber risk management portal that includes the most updated information on emerging cyber threats and the latest reports on risk mitigation measures and practices.
Bottom line: SMBs need to be as proactive as their larger counterparts by: (1) conducting proper risk assessment and quantification; (2) investing in a cyber-savvy culture; (3) insuring cyber threats they can’t mitigate and; (4) allocating enough capital to technological cyber defenses.
Learn more about comprehensive cybersecurity from Willis Towers Watson.
David Hau is the Vice President of Cyber and the National Middle Market Leader for Cyber and E&O insurance for FINEX, as well as a senior broker.
Jason Krauss is a thought and product leader for Cyber and E&O insurance for FINEX.